Chat with us, powered by LiveChat

Finding Profitable HMO Tenants That Pay on Time.

This week, we’ve been reminding ourselves of the benefit of testing, and how to find profitable HMO tenants in any market. You may know that we’ve focused on single-let properties over HMO type units in the past.

This week, we’ve been reminding ourselves of the benefit of testing, and how to find profitable HMO tenants in any market. You may know that we’ve focused on single-let properties over HMO type units in the past.

You see, many of our experiences stem from trying to use our local housing allowance [LHA] model, which we use on single-let properties in an HMO environment.

Unlike families claiming housing benefits, the single-person room model just doesn’t seem to work with tenants claiming benefits.

Let me show you the difference between the two properties we own that are opposite each other on the same street, of exactly the same size and type, but managed by 2 different letting agents. One letting to LHA tenants claim benefits and the other to working professionals.

Bullet 1

HMO Property 1:

Property-1

HMO Property 2:

Property-2

The difference between the two HMO properties is stunning!

One agent clearly does a better job than the other [even managing to provide such amazing things as monthly rental statements!], but most of this is down to the fact that single benefits claimants attracted to HMO accommodation appear to have a higher propensity for being in and out of prison, involved with drugs [we took 130 needles out of one we cleared after sacking a terrible agent!] and theft.

These factors mean that other tenants in the building move out a lot more often, creating huge voids and non-payment of rent for the tenants who end up in prison.

Of course, the agents involved in both of these models told us up front how much each investment strategy would work, so the question arises, how do you decide which route/letting agent to go with when making the decision on which strategy to follow?

Test to find the most profitable HMO tenants…

An early mistake we made investing in property was to rely on what we had been told by people and market participants about expected returns…

We would often find a model that we believed worked, and quickly purchase a large number of units, outlaying capital on refurbs without first securing the income stream.

These days we frequently try new things, but if we want to try a new model we will often do the following things:

1. Test the market and tenants for the property type above

2. or buy a few properties at any one time

AND then test the return from the LHA tenant and one with a private tenant with different managing agents.

We will then assess the results after around 6 months and start to move in the direction which seems to be working.

Are you new to HMO property investing?

The video below will give you great tips on how to get your first HMO.

Due diligence is all good, but it can only take you so far: you then need to just jump in at the shallow end, and make sure you watch like a hawk, keeping track of the financials every month, to scale later.

“If you go as far as you can see, you will then see enough to go even farther” — John Wooden

For more information about finding the right HMO tenants, join our Progressive Property Community.

Finished reading?
- Take the next step.

If you are ready to take the next steps on your property journey

then our upcoming webinar is the perfect place to start.

About Progressive Property

Progressive Property has created more property millionaires and success stories in the UK than any other property investing education provider. Since 2007, Rob Moore, Mark Homer and their team of experts have built a welcoming, tight knit community to help people achieve freedom, choice and profit by investing in property.

Zoom Logo

Join Our Next Upcoming Webinar!

Property Investing: Take Control Of Your Financial Future TODAY.

Register now
Open CTA

Related stories

Why Direct Property Investment CRUSHES Property Funds in 2026

Why Direct Property Investment CRUSHES Property Funds in 2026

The Ultimate 2026 Guide to Property Finance

The Ultimate 2026 Guide to Property Finance

What Is a "Good" Property Yield in 2026?

What Is a "Good" Property Yield in 2026?

favicon

Don't miss anything.

Sign up to our newsletter to get access to the newest events, latest promotions and stay up to date.

*We do not give financial advice, we just share our 20 years experience on what has worked for us, & warn you about & openly share what has not. We do not do get rich quick, we do get richer for longer. No schemes, just strategies. we are not an IFA, and we do not give professional advice, we simply educate entrepreneurial people who are smart & make their own decisions. We regularly suggest you do your own due diligence & research before making your investments. And we are here to help. To see our legal disclaimer, click here

© Progressive Property 2026  •  Privacy  •  Terms  •  Cookies  •  Disclaimer  Ambassador Terms  Payments UK Limited